Soccer, known as football outside of North America, is universally loved, and it has produced a plethora of incredible players throughout its storied history. Fans around the world often debate who holds the title of the "best soccer player in the world ever." This article delves deep into the contenders, evaluates their merits, and walks you through the reasons behind the varied opinions.
Icons of the Game: The Contenders
Era: 1957 1977
Nationality: Brazilian
Achievements: 3 FIFA World Cups (1958, 1962, 1970), over 1,200 career goals.
Pelé is often the first name that comes up in discussions about the greatest of all time. His skill, technique, and ability to perform on the biggest stages are unmatched. He played for Santos FC for most of his career and mesmerized fans with his incredible scoring ability and dribbling finesse.
Era: 1976 1997

Nationality: Argentine
Achievements: FIFA World Cup (1986), numerous domestic titles with Napoli and Boca Juniors.
Maradona's legacy is enshrined in the hearts of soccer lovers. His 'Hand of God' goal and stunning solo effort against England in the '86 World Cup highlight his unparalleled skill and controversial persona. His influence on the game and ability to inspire teammates are aspects that cement his place among the elite.
Era: 2004 Present
Nationality: Argentine
Achievements: 7 Ballon d'Or awards, 10 La Liga titles, UEFA Champions League titles.
Messi has shattered numerous records, including being Barcelona's alltime top scorer and the highest goal scorer in La Liga history. His vision, dribbling ability, and goalscoring prowess transcend the sport. Many experts and fans argue that his combination of technical skills and achievements makes him the best of all time.
Era: 2002 Present
Nationality: Portuguese
Achievements: 5 Ballon d'Or awards, UEFA Champions League titles with multiple clubs, national successes with Portugal.
Ronaldo is celebrated for his incredible athleticism, work ethic, and goalscoring ability. He has been a top performer for every club he has played with, including Manchester United, Real Madrid, and Juventus. His remarkable consistency keeps him in the conversation as the greatest ever.
Era: 1964 1984
Nationality: Dutch
Achievements: 3 Ballon d'Or awards, known for revolutionary influence on tactics and style of play.
Cruyff was not only a phenomenal player but also an inspirational coach. His philosophy and vision for the game paved the way for modern soccer. He was pivotal in the development of 'Total Football,' making a lasting impact on how the sport is played today.
More Icons to Consider
While Pelé, Maradona, Messi, and Ronaldo often dominate the discussion, other legends, such as Zinedine Zidane, Michel Platini, and George Best, also warrant consideration. Each of these players had defining moments that left indelible marks on the sport.
Factors in the Debate: What Makes a Player the Best?
Determining the greatest player in soccer history hinges on various factors:
Skill Level: Technical abilities, dribbling, passing, and shooting skills.
Achievements: Titles won at both club and international levels.
Influence on the Game: How they changed the landscape of football and inspired other players.
Longevity and Consistency: Performance over an extended period versus peak performance.
Personal Style: Individual flair and creativity that sets a player apart.
Tips to Enhance Your Soccer Viewing Experience
Example: After a game, read tactics breakdowns on platforms like The Athletic or listen to podcasts like “The Total Soccer Show” to understand intricate game details.
Example: Rewatch the 1986 World Cup quarter match between Argentina and England to see Maradona’s brilliance firsthand.
Example: Participate in discussions on Reddit’s r/soccer or the various soccer forums available on dedicated sports websites.
Example: Look up Messi’s career statistics to see how they stack against other greats.
Example: Visiting a UEFA Champions League match allows you to feel the intensity that contrasts with watching on a screen.
Frequently Asked Questions
Pelé's record as a threetime World Cup winner (1958, 1962, 1970) and his vast goalscoring achievements have positioned him among the top candidates.
Lionel Messi's unparalleled dribbling skills, vision, and goalscoring consistency, along with his numerous records and awards, make a compelling case for his legacy.
This is subjective and depends on personal opinions, criteria, and the era in which one grew up watching the game. Each player has different qualities that resonate with fans.
Maradona's flair and largerthanlife character not only brought joy on the pitch but also left a profound cultural impact, particularly in Argentina and Naples, where he played.
Both players have unique styles; Messi's playmaking contrasts Ronaldo's athletic power and aerial ability. Their careers and achievements often serve as a direct comparison.
Many fans debate that Johann Cruyff was the most "complete" due to his revolutionary tactics, style, and successful career as a player and coach.
Debating who the best soccer player in the world ever is may never find a definitive answer. With legends like Pelé, Maradona, Messi, and Ronaldo, each player brings their unique flavor to the beautiful game. Understanding the factors that contribute to greatness, alongside engaging in the sport and its rich history, allows fans to appreciate the legends that have shaped soccer as we know it today.
Is there a player we may have overlooked? Who do you believe deserves the title? Join the conversation!